Need help!! Trying Junior Brown’s C13 tuning on my 8string

Nathan Farlow · From: North Carolina, USA

Don’t think I’m holding my mouth right. So I haven’t found anything that tells the best string gauges to use for it. I bought Andy Volk’s “Slide Rules book awhile back because I stumbled across it while researching tunings because I hadn’t found one that truly I’m a fan of yet. Been doing G6/Em7 since I put my benders on and it’s fine and makes the transition to 8-string from 6 easier but it’s just kind of meh. So saw the Junior Brown C13 tuning in the Andy Volk book and I’m a huge JB fan so I set out to try it. Ordered a custom set off StringJoy and just finally getting around to changing over to it today.

This is the tuning in the book
(In parenthesis is my interpretation)
G (high 5th) (.010)
E (high 3rd) (.014)
C (high root) (.015)
A (6th) (.020p)
G (5th) (.024w)
E (3rd) (.034)
C (root) (.054)
Bb (low 7th) (.070)

Am I correct in my interpretation? Popped my high G when tuning it up. I found this photo when originally researching it and surely he doesn’t use that .014 for the high G? Or am I an octave high on the first 4 strings?

Thanks

Joe A. Roberts · From: Seoul, South Korea

That G you used should have worked, it was probably binding on the bridge or nut which can happen on those skinny strings. What scale length are you using?
The G being too thin sounding it a common issue you'll hear about so I have heard about people using really heavy strings on G... Personally I'd just shift everything down to A6th.

Those low strings on the back of that guitar seem crazy thick too, .054 for C seems like way too much, and especially that low Bb unless he is tuning it an octave lower.
And why only .15 for the C? String pulls?

Nathan Farlow · From: North Carolina, USA

Roland Sturm · From: Santa Monica, CA

I think your interpretation is for a different tuning. When I look at the picture you posted, I would guess at something like this: (high to low) E C A G E C Bb C.
So the top string in the picture may be intended for E and the bottom string (70) for a C an octave down from the C in the usual tuning. Then the 54, mmh, could be as high as Bb or could be as low as G or F

For what you seem to be after, I have an 12 for the high G (1st string), an 18 for the high C (3rd string), a 46 for the low C (7 string) and a 56 for the A (bottom string, which you want to tune up to Bb).

In summary: you may show a Jules Ah See tuning, but want a Junior Brown. So add a high G, move all the other strings one down, and don't use the 70.

Alex Cattaneo · From: Quebec, Canada

I actually put a 014 on my Guyatone for a high G and I like it so far! I had a 12 but that was little too thin for my taste, and I didn’t have 013 on hand. In any case, 010 seems too thin. Joe Ely recommends 012, and on a small scale neck (22.5), I would try 013 or 014. It’s cool to see the JB is using a 014!

For a 22.5” scale, I would go 13, 15 and 18 for g, e and c. John Ely recommends 12, 14 and 17, but I’m guessing that’s for a 24.5” scale guitar.

Mike Neer · From: NJ

These would be incorrect gauges for Junior Brown’s C13 and more suitable for Jules Ah See’s C13.
The low Bb in Junior’s tuning would only be in the .040 range. (
As far as .014 for the high G, that is too heavy in my opinion.
_________________
Links to streaming music, websites, YouTube: Links

D Schubert · From: Columbia, MO, USA

I have that tuning on my Stringmaster, and use the 8 string E13 sets that are sold on SGF for the JB tuning. That's 0.012" on top and 0.042" on the bottom.
_________________
GFI Expo S-10PE, Sho-Bud 6139, Fender 2x8 Stringmaster, Supro consoles, Dobro. And more.

Tony Oresteen · From: Georgia, USA

What is the scale length of your instrument?
_________________
Tony
Newnan, GA

Too many guitars, not enough time to play
'72 Sho-Bud 6139, '71 Marlen 210
'78 Fender Stringmaster T8 black
PedalMaster D8

Nathan Farlow · From: North Carolina, USA

Nathan Farlow · From: North Carolina, USA

Mike Neer · From: NJ

Nathan Farlow · From: North Carolina, USA

Allan Revich · From: Victoria, BC

Nic Neufeld · From: Kansas City, Missouri

JAS C13 and Junior C13 are basically the same tuning for seven strings, just the former adds a low C on the bottom, the latter adds a high G on top. A .070 is what I use for my LOW C...ain't no way to tune that up to the correct Bb unless you are using a, I dunno, piano scale length. Smile

_________________
Waikīkī, at night when the shadows are falling
I hear the rolling surf calling
Calling and calling to me

Joe A. Roberts · From: Seoul, South Korea

Just came across this post by Ron Whitfield from 2003:

“As Lynn mentioned using a .015 at the top to solve the thinny sound for a G, I needed at least a .016 to get it to sound correct on my Rick B8. Not too stiff and I've not broken one yet.”

Wow! At least a .016!

I personally like a reentrant D on top:

d
E
C
A
G
E
C
Bb

Dave Mudgett · From: Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee

You can take the guesswork out of string gauges by using a string tension calculator. You're using stringjoy strings - why not use their string tension calculator, which is specifically designed for their strings - https://tension.stringjoy.com/?

Typical "nominal" string tensions for lap/console string sets are around 30 pounds per string - plus or minus whatever you like, and sometimes there are good reasons to go over or under - e.g., if you just like a lower or higher tension, or want to pull a string. For hi-lo G4-E4-C4-A3-G3-E3-C3-Bb2, that yields around 12-13p, 15p, 18-19p OR 18-20w, 24w, 28w, 32w, 42w, 48w - these are slightly heavier than 30 lb, go a gauge lighter for a little lighter than 30 lb.

I assume 54 and 70 for the bottom two are for an octave lower - the tensions at C3 and Bb2 are around 51 and 67 pounds, respectively. They might not break, but that seems unreasonably high to me. But I get around 13 and 17 pounds for the octave-lower C2 and Bb1, respectively. Those would feel real floppy to me, but if one is going for a floppy baritone guitar type of feel, that might work.

As far as breaking strings go - that .010 for G4 should in principle tune up with no problem. But light strings at high tension are more sensitive to imperfections in anything. Issue with string, burr in nut or saddle, pulling a string too hard, whatever. Tension is around 20 pounds for G4 at 22.75" scale, which is light to my tastes also. Even pedal steel at 24-24.25" scale typically uses .011, .0115, or .012 gauge strings for G#4, which is bent up to A4 constantly. Of course, that is the pedal steel string most likely to break. But .010, even at the longer scale, sounds very thin to me. I don't know anybody who uses .010 for pedal steel G#4, although I imagine there are some players who do.

In general, within reason, increasing string gauge from a reasonable nominal tension at a particular pitch does not necessarily increase string breakage. The reason is that although the string tension goes up, so does the cross-sectional area, and thus the tensile strength, of the string. There is a point in the string tension vs. gauge curve where it becomes very nonlinear and the tension starts going up much faster than the tensile strength and the string pretty much always breaks. But I often find that moderate increases in tension actually reduce string breakage. For example, I run some Telecasters with a 12-52 set with a 20p third so I can still bend it a whole tone with no wonkiness. I have never, ever broken a string on those Teles. I would break strings with 9-42 sets all the time, 10-46 sets periodically, but almost never break strings on 11-48 sets. Heavy strings are heresy among many if not most electric guitar players, but I set gauges for these 12-52 sets at around 25-26 pounds per string, and they play just fine, can be bent with no problem, permit rapid alternate flatpicking as on an acoustic guitar, and never break, at least in my experience.

BTW - looking at your photo, I read hi-low 14, 15, (17 or 19, hard to tell for sure), 20p, 24w, 30, 54, 70, not 10, 14, 15, 20p, 24w, 34, 54, 70.

Mike Nihen · From: Fairfax, VA

The photo is of my guit-steel. The tape I used bled though the tape and melted into the finish. I should shoot myself later. Please disregard.

Shea Stevenson · From: Alabama, USA

Where’s the “f”? I don’t get why it’s called “13” without the F….
_________________
Ric m59 - Ce3 - Ge7 - Memphis Sun - Supro Thunderbolt 1x15

Allan Revich · From: Victoria, BC

Shea Stevenson · From: Alabama, USA

Mike Neer · From: NJ

You don’t usually use the 11 in a 13 chord because it clashes with the 3rd and creates a suspension. It is more common to see a #11, which avoids that clash.
_________________
Links to streaming music, websites, YouTube: Links

Jim Rossen · From: Iowa, USA

I play the C13 tuning with string 8 Bb one step below the string 7 C and am happy with the C6 8 string SIT set from the forum store plus a .011 string for the high G. The .054 string is not used.

Jim

Forum Index > Steel Without Pedals		Next oldest topic :: Next newest topic