| Visit Our Catalog at SteelGuitarShopper.com |

Post new topic Chromatics or Diatonics?
Reply to topic
Author Topic:  Chromatics or Diatonics?
John Larson


From:
Pennsyltucky, USA
Post  Posted 26 May 2024 5:28 pm    
Reply with quote

So the E9 tuning for 10 string pedal steel is commonly referred to a E9 Chromatic due to the presence of the top two strings that Buddy Emmons added to complete a major scale without moving the bar wherein these strings are commonly referred to as chromatics. Why are these strings commonly referred to as chromatics? Properly they would be diatonics as the notes D# and F# are indeed found within the E major scale as the 2nd and 7th degrees of the scale. The re and ti in solfege.
E, F#, G#, A, B, C#, D#
do, re, mi, fa, sol, la, ti

The only note not properly found in an E major scale is the 9th string D which is used to form the minor 7th of the E 9th chord. E major triad (E, G#, B) plus minor 7th (D) and major 9th (F#) (Octave plus a 2nd).

Anyway to cut to the chase shouldn't this tuning properly be referred to as E9th Diatonic?

Is this like Fender permanently confounding the terms vibrato and tremolo?
_________________
Rejoice in the Lord, O ye righteous; praise is meet for the upright. Give praise to the Lord with the harp, chant unto Him with the ten-stringed psaltery. Sing unto Him a new song, chant well unto Him with jubilation. For the word of the Lord is true, and all His works are in faithfulness. The Lord loveth mercy and judgement; the earth is full of the mercy of the Lord.
- Psalm 33:1-5
View user's profile Send private message
Paul Strojan

 

From:
California, USA
Post  Posted 26 May 2024 9:09 pm    
Reply with quote

The D# is chromatic to the A major scale. My theory is that the original E9 pedal steel copedent was setup around A major not E major. Most non pedal players primary tuning is a 6th rather than a 9th tuning. On the original Isaacs’ set up, the 4 accessible tunings were E9 open (E, G#, B, D, F#, G#, B, E); A6 ( E, A, C#, E, F#, A, C#, E); E9 over A6 (E, A, C#, E, F#, G#, B, E) and D major 7/ E11 ( E, G#, B, D, F#, A, C#, E). With this set up the A is the one chord of the copedent. As the pedal steel guitar evolved the focus moved from A to E being the one chord there became a need to get the D# and F# for a B major chord.
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Dave Mudgett


From:
Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
Post  Posted 26 May 2024 9:43 pm    
Reply with quote

If you read this thread, you'll see that even Buddy Emmons didn't know for sure who started the terminology 'chromatic' - https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=163639 - but he suspects it came from Shot Jackson, probably in the early 60s. Quite a number of very knowledgeable people posted on that thread.

If you want to read a bunch of arcane discussions about why diatonic or chromatic is 'correct' (or not), feel free to dive into these threads from 2009:

https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=163104

https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=163322

I started the first thread above because so many people have speculated about this for a long time. I figured, maybe someone out there actually knows. But I think that true first-hand knowledge of the term's origin may well be lost to posterity.

Oh - and here's another related discussion from a year earlier - https://bb.steelguitarforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=141901
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Ian Rae


From:
Redditch, England
Post  Posted 27 May 2024 2:02 am    
Reply with quote

"Diatonic" would be a useless term, as all the other strings are diatonic too. "Re-entrant" is the most logical, but it's not as cool and technical-sounding as "chromatic", which I'm sure will persist despite being inappropriate except when lowering D# to D.

And who ever refers to the "E# lever"? - cos that's what it is...
_________________
Make sleeping dogs tell the truth!
Homebuilt keyless U12 7x5, Excel keyless U12 8x8, Williams keyless U12 7x8, Telonics rack and 15" cabs


Last edited by Ian Rae on 27 May 2024 6:15 am; edited 1 time in total
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Nick Fryer


From:
Ohio, USA
Post  Posted 27 May 2024 4:03 am    
Reply with quote

My take on it is that the added strings allow you to create a lot of chromaticism D# - E - F - F# - G - G# - A
_________________
www.fryerguitarpickups.com
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Fred Treece


From:
California, USA
Post  Posted 27 May 2024 6:19 am    
Reply with quote

E9 is a chord name, not a scale or Key name.

The 5 notes in an E9 chord are E-G#-B-D-F# (1-3-5-7-9). A beautiful chord!

String 2 of E9 pedal steel tuning is D#.

D# is indeed diatonic to the E major scale, but it is chromatic (non-diatonic?) to the E9 chord. An outlier, a rogue, a hobo, an alien.

String 1 (F#) is not a chromatic note of the E9 chord. It is the 9th, the chord’s very namesake.

I agree that the top 2 strings of E9 can be called “re-entrant”, but that is a physical term, not a musically descriptive one.

I doubt that you will find the term “E9 chromatic” anywhere in music theory. It is a made-up convention for pedal steel guitar, and for 60 years so far, it is the least ridiculous way to describe the open tuning.
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Fred Treece


From:
California, USA
Post  Posted 27 May 2024 2:32 pm    
Reply with quote

Sorry for that haughty post, but the nomenclature for E9 tuning threw me for a loop when I first started playing, too. I think it’s worth a discussion occasionally, and the only way to bring clarity to it is to mention the history behind it like Dave M. did, and maybe try to get inside and behind the pretzel logic of why it stuck while admitting the confounding flaws.
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Tucker Jackson

 

From:
Portland, Oregon, USA
Post  Posted 27 May 2024 6:04 pm    
Reply with quote

Quote:
Sorry for that haughty post...

Not haughty at all. It started down a good path, made a strong argument and answered the OP's technical question. I would have only added a few more sentences to the end of your post to zoom out a level and bring things from the theoretical back to the practical world:

"...“E9 chromatic”... is the least ridiculous way to describe the open tuning."

"But, luckily, we don't live in a world where we must use the strictly technical description. If we did, we might be tempted to call the 10-string C6 tuning Csus4-6-Add9 (or maybe C6-Add9-Add11) -- since there are 2 strings there that aren't part of a C6 chord. But a name like that would be both technically correct... and ridiculous.

It's fun to have these intellectual excercises, but a common real world convention is to name tunings by the chord that most of the strings form and ignore the outlier strings that don't fit the chord. Though it may not be wrong to include the outlier strings and call it "E9 Chromatic," and it may not be wrong to call it "Csus4-6-Add9"... we're lucky we can be a little imprecise and just call them E9 and C6.
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Ian Rae


From:
Redditch, England
Post  Posted 28 May 2024 12:03 am    
Reply with quote

"Least ridiculous" is good enough for me Smile
_________________
Make sleeping dogs tell the truth!
Homebuilt keyless U12 7x5, Excel keyless U12 8x8, Williams keyless U12 7x8, Telonics rack and 15" cabs
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
John Hyland

 

From:
South Australia
Post  Posted 28 May 2024 1:32 pm    
Reply with quote

Interesting academic discussion but I don’t see much reference chromatic very often these days. In the years past maybe, but now go with the flow and just call it E9 and consign chromatic to a historic oddity.
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail

All times are GMT - 8 Hours
Jump to:  
Please review our Forum Rules and Policies
Our Online Catalog
Strings, CDs, instruction, and steel guitar accessories
www.SteelGuitarShopper.com

The Steel Guitar Forum
148 S. Cloverdale Blvd.
Cloverdale, CA 95425 USA

Click Here to Send a Donation

Email SteelGuitarForum@gmail.com for technical support.


BIAB Styles
Ray Price Shuffles for Band-in-a-Box
by Jim Baron