Volume Pedal question

Bill OCallaghan · From: Trenton, NJ USA

Hello folks, I am still a newbie on the PSG, I would like to know if there is any special about a volume pedal for PSG vs for guitar. I have been looking and see alot on ebay very inexpensive (ernie ball), but the ones that specifically mention PSG (goodrich) seem much more expensive. Is the a difference? something I should be looking out for?

Thanks!!
Bill

Jim Peters · From: St. Louis, Missouri, USA, R.I.P.

Hi Bill,one thing to think about is the plug jacks being on the side of the pedal rather than the front, where they cords will interfere with the pedal bar. The pots are basically the same. A new Carter starter pedal is $100, and works just fine. JP
_________________
Carter,PV,Fender

David Hartley · Posted 13 Apr 2008 6:26 am **Hi Bill**

You are a newbie to PSG so you must have just bought one I presume? This steel must have been a big outlay in the onset. In my very honest opinion, the pedal is the next thing you must INVEST in.. Ok yes, I have used GOODRICH for years and they are absolutely fine. I know you must have a budget, but if you can afford a GOODRICH, get one. BUT I must say though, it's not until you use a HILTON electronic pedal designed specifically for steel that you will realise how much you've been missing out on.. IMO, get out the barclaycard, sell something, beg, borrow, steel (sorry!) and buy a HILTON.. You really wont regret it..

DAVID HARTLEY

Larry Bell · From: Englewood, Florida

I agree with everything said. I have two Hiltons and a Goodrich. Love 'em.

The point about the in's and out's coming out the front of the pedal is important. Another important consideration when comparing volume pedals designed for guitar vs those designed for steel is HOW they are used. A guitarist tends to 'set it and forget it'. The guitarist will boost volume for solos but will not stand there with his/her foot on the pedal. A steel player, on the other hand, puts A LOT MORE MILES on that pedal. It gets much more use in a 4 hour gig than a volume pedal used by a guitar player.

Pots have inherent characteristics that can create problems. They wear out -- obviously more rapidly the more often you move it. They get scratchy before they give out completely. They color the tone when the control is not 'wide open'. For those and other reasons, a potless pedal like the Hilton or Goodrich LDR is used by a lot of steel players, despite the higher price. There's nothing more frustrating than to have your volume pedal crap out on you in the last set of a club gig.

Get the best equipment you can afford. In many cases you get what you pay for. Good luck on your pedal steel quest. It can be a fun ride.
_________________
Larry Bell - email: larry@larrybell.org - gigs - Home Page
My CD's: 'I've Got Friends in COLD Places' - 'Pedal Steel Guitar'
2021 Rittenberry S/D-12 8x7, 1976 Emmons S/D-12 7x6, 1969 Emmons S/D-12 6x6, 1971 Dobro, Quilter ToneBlock 202 TT-12

CrowBear Schmitt · From: Ariege, - PairO'knees, - France

volume pedals for psg are specific to the instrument Bill
an ernie ball vp has a 250k pot
(for single coil pick ups like fender teles & strats)
certain ernie ball vps have the input & output jacks on the front which does'nt make it suitable for a psg
it's like Jim P mentions
other vps that are specific to psgs have a 500k pot ( for double coils pick ups) & have 1 input jack & 2 output jacks on the side which are made for psgs
save up yer $$$ & get a goodrich120, or carter
you can also find a good used one here on the forum too

eventually, what you call a volume pedal Bill,will eventually become an "expression pedal"

Ken Metcalf · From: San Antonio Texas USA

Test them if you can.
Hilton versus Ernie Ball is like night and day.
Many here including myself have an old vol. ped. that doesn't even get used for prac. and i thought the old vol. ped sounded ok until I used them side by side.
I have a friend that has a new Emmmons and an old funky Vol pedal he is always working on it and complaining about it.

Ken
_________________
MSA 12 String E9th/B6th Universal.
Little Walter PF-89.
Bunch of stomp boxes

Clyde Mattocks · From: Kinston, North Carolina, USA

I went to do a recording session and found to my horror that I had left my expensive pedal home.
There was a cheap plastic volume pedal for an
electronic keyboard there that I commandeered. I
got thru the session fine with it. I think one of
the factors at play in price is the materials in the
housing more so than the electronics. The steel
guitar pedal suppliers make fewer and use heavier
stuff (cast aluminum in most cases) while the
suppliers for the other instruments mass produce them. I have an Ernic Ball that I use with lap steel and other intruments that work pretty well.
_________________
LeGrande II, Nash. 112, Fender Twin Tone Master, Session 400, Harlow Dobro, R.Q.Jones Dobro

Donny Hinson · From: Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.

Charles Davidson · From: Phenix City Alabama, USA

For a beginner that can't afford one of the expensive pedals[Hilton etc]A Morley Little gater will do the job,for about sixty bucks,[This is just my opinion]know some will disagree.I like the Goodrich pedals had two I used for years,the pots lasted for years,After seven or eight years had to replace the pots,the new pots did'nt last two weeks,Could'nt afford to spend around three hundred bucks for a high dollar pedal,also don't like to have to plug one in,Bought the Little Gator,it's adjustable and uses a nine volt battery that lasts for months,[NO POT],the only draw back it's a little wider than most pedals,but is real stable.For the money it's a bargain.DYKBC.
_________________
Hard headed, opinionated old geezer. BAMA CHARLIE. GOD BLESS AMERICA. ANIMAL RIGHTS ACTIVIST. SUPPORT LIVE MUSIC !

John Billings · From: Ohio, USA

I use Goodrich and Shobud pot pedals I wanted to try a friends Visual Sound pedal, but the jacks were in the front! Big problem? No! I just used cables with right-angle jacks. The VS pedal didn't sound bad. Gotz a bunch of lights that light up. It also has a jack for a tuner..

Brint Hannay · From: Maryland, USA

Another factor is the feel of the pedal. I have used Ernie Ball volume pedals for many years for guitar, and the ones I have are older, from when they had the jacks on the side, but I find that they have a stiffer feel, probably because, as mentioned, guitar players most often set it and leave it. Even pot pedals designed for steel guitar use have a freer-floating feel, which lends itself much better to expressive use, IMHO.

Jeremy Threlfall · From: now in Western Australia

My Ernie Ball pedal works fine

Some people prefer the old pot pedals because they DO colour the sound the more they are closed off

the classic pedal steel cuts from the 50s and 60s would have been made with pot pedals, I suppose.

Lee Baucum · From: McAllen, Texas (Extreme South) The Final Frontier

Here is some good reading.

CLICK HERE

Lee, from South Texas

Donny Hinson · From: Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.

We all have heard statements about the way that pots "steal highs", "color the sound", or "suck the tone".

I'd just like to remind everyone that pots are found not only in pedal steel volume pedals, but they're also found in straight guitars, lap and console steels, electric mandolins, and electric bass guitars.

Isn't it strange that players of those instruments never seem quite as concerned about the supposed bad effects of using a pot as avolume control? Oddly enough, some straight guitars even have two (pot) volume controls in them!!!

So...I guess they're...twice as sucky???

Laughing

Twayn Williams · From: Portland, OR

Brint Hannay · From: Maryland, USA

Donny Hinson · From: Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.

Greg Cutshaw · From: Corry, PA, USA

Will someone please go back and tell Ralph Mooney, Lloyd Green and Pete Drake etc. that their pot pedal sucked all the highs out of their recordings for over 3 decades both in a recording and a live setting. You can get all the highs out of any pot pedal you want with adjustments in cords and amp settings.

I use both the Hilton and the pot pedal and both work just fine. I'd give the pot pedal a little edge for the kind of tone I like best. Reliablilty is a toss up if your pot pedal has a good conductive plastic pot in it, it will likely run over 10 years with no problem and certainly will outlast even the old design Allen Bradley pots. The Hilton and the Goodrich pot pedals do produce different tones and dynamics so their signature sound is a little different. At the PSGA show I recently attended, there were lots of pros with awesome sound using pot pedals and no buffer amp. It just isn't needed to get a good sound. There were also pros there using the Hilton and getting awesome sound.

Either pedal will do a fine job. Try both and pick the one that gives you the tone you like best.

Greg

Brint Hannay · From: Maryland, USA

I agree with you, Donny and Greg. The treble reduction with a pot pedal is slight, and is nothing that can't be more than compensated for by amp settings.

I slightly prefer the sound of a pot pedal myself. But I use a Hilton because of the problems with pot quality a few years back. I haven't yet experienced the new plastic resistance path pots.

Jim Peters · From: St. Louis, Missouri, USA, R.I.P.

I've had guitars with the cap on the pot mod, and hated the way the treble didn't roll off by lowering my volume. You can negate almost all of the tone changes on pedal steel very easily, by putting nearly any Boss or Ibanez pedal between your guitar and volume pedal. The buffer amp in the effect pedal negates any impedance problems. The 3 chord setup used with PV Nashville amps also eliminates most issues of tone degradation. I use an Ibanez delay right out of my steel,or the 3 cord method, or both. Not only is my tone consistent, the little bit of scratchy pot noise is almost completely eliminated. The buffered pedals also negate the tone loss caused by poor cables. Buying a buffered pedal is an inexpensive way to regulate your tone. JP
_________________
Carter,PV,Fender

chris ivey · From: california (deceased)

in the past, plug in volume pedals used to be way more bass-y and edgeless.....is the hilton better about that. i use a goodrich w/10k pot pedal...sounds fine and low impedance line level...

David Hartley · Posted 14 Apr 2008 1:13 pm **Greg**

Dont you think though that if these Hiltons were available in them early days, the steel players you mentioned would be using them? ANSWER IS PROBABLY YES..

It is without a doubt an unbeatable unit IMO (as they say)..

You will never get the modern recordings like them old records again. I just love the way you can hear either Lloyd's or his drummers stool squeeking at the end of most of his instrumentals on the HITS album.. MONO TOO

And GREG, many thanks for the .xls file you sent me, it is VERY much appreciated and I will have a play around with it soon..

David Hartley

Bill OCallaghan · From: Trenton, NJ USA

Wow, thanks for all the responses on this. I never cease to learn something here. I am glad I held off on an impulse to buy a used EB bol pedal and will take a little more time in making my decision.

thank you all for your insight, much appreciated.

Bill

Doug Seymour · From: Jamestown NY USA (deceased)

I don't believe anyone has mentioned the height of different pedals? That was always an issue for me. I always used the low models, your results may vary.

Gabriel Stutz · From: Chicago, USA

I will say that I prefer my Hilton tonally over any pot pedal I've played. I prefer the highs to stay basically the same throughout the travel.

In the end, the reason I didn't like the pot pedals wasn't so much the tonal change itself, but the inconsistency of the tonal change. As the pot wore out the amount of change went up and up until it became scratchy and needed to be replaced. So it bothered me that basically every time I used the pedal it sounded a little worse (to me) than the time before. I also got incredibly tired of changing pots.

The one thing more specific to the question that I've noticed is that the VPs made for guitar seem so have a longer throw than the ones for steel (in some active pedals, the throw is adjustable). I takes a lot more motion to go from full on to minimum volume. It was very uncomfortable for me when I was using a guitar volume pedal.

Gabriel

Forum Index > Electronics	Goto page 1, 2 Next	Next oldest topic :: Next newest topic