| Author |
Topic: Is this really an 11th chord? |
b0b
From:
Cloverdale, CA, USA
|
Posted 28 Jun 2022 11:22 pm |
|
I'm playing with our guitar player's chord chart that for a song that includes a C11 chord. It seemed to me that I should be able to play a C9 (easy chord on steel) but it clashed. When I asked him what he's playing, he said "it's the easiest chord on the guitar" and showed me this position:
To my way of thinking, that's a C9sus4. The low E of my C9 (or C11, or C13) clashes with his F. I need to raise it. So it's really a sus chord, right?
Should I make him change his chart, or just skip the 3rd whenever I see an 11th chord? 
(What he's playing sounds right, it's just the chord name that confuses me.)
_________________
-πππ- (admin) - Robert P. Lee - Recordings - Breathe - D6th - Video |
|
|
 |
Ken Pippus
From:
Langford, BC, Canada
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 12:06 am
|
|
| The 11th should appear high in the voicing, so itβs not close the 3. Kinda like a maj7. |
|
|
|
Earnest Bovine
From:
Los Angeles CA USA
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 5:10 am
|
|
| Yes, that's what C11 means on a chord chart. Alternatively, you could write Gm7/C or C9sus4, but those take longer to write. |
|
|
|
John Sluszny
From:
Brussels, Belgium
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 7:58 am
|
|
| Should be easier to say if we knew the chords BEFORE and AFTER this one ! (and the bass line too) |
|
|
|
Dave Mudgett
From:
Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 8:14 am
|
|
Yes, technically it's a voicing of the C11 chord. The notes are out of stacked 3rds starting at C, and the b7 and 11 are present, 13 not present. There are several possible names for it - e.g., taking the Bb as root, it's a 2 5 1 3 6 = Bb6/C or 6/2 chord or as Doug states, Gm7/C or m7/11. There's a reasonable spelling as an F chord, although I have a hard time imagining it use it that way in the context of typical popular music. I guess you could call it a D chord too, but it just doesn't sound like a D chord in any context I can think of.
Unless I was playing the exact same chord/voicing, what I would play there would depend on the context, or what the bass player is playing. Could be a C, G, or Bb. If I was playing that as a C chord, I would probably avoid the 3 (E) note altogether - it clashes in any context I can think of when I play it on guitar.
My basic rule - if comping on a complex chord or scale, eliminate notes until it sounds good. |
|
|
|
Jeremy Reeves
From:
Springfield, IL, USA
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 9:44 am
|
|
| I'd want to know the chord in the measure before and after and what melody notes are in that specific measure with the 11th, unless youre just vamping on that chord... |
|
|
|
b0b
From:
Cloverdale, CA, USA
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 1:37 pm
|
|
| Jeremy Reeves wrote: |
| I'd want to know the chord in the measure before and after and what melody notes are in that specific measure with the 11th, unless youre just vamping on that chord... |
It's a Cm7 before and after. Back and forth. No melody in that section of the song. It eventually resolves through Cm7 Gm7 to EbMaj7 (the song's in Eb).
_________________
-πππ- (admin) - Robert P. Lee - Recordings - Breathe - D6th - Video |
|
|
|
Jeremy Reeves
From:
Springfield, IL, USA
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 2:45 pm
|
|
| b0b wrote: |
| Jeremy Reeves wrote: |
| I'd want to know the chord in the measure before and after and what melody notes are in that specific measure with the 11th, unless youre just vamping on that chord... |
It's a Cm7 before and after. Back and forth. No melody in that section of the song. It eventually resolves through Cm7 Gm7 to EbMaj7 (the song's in Eb). |
so it's Contrapuntal Elaboration of Static Harmony 
but really just seems like it might be some kind of basic vamp on C-7 with a little variety thrown in. I'd call the chord a C-11 just to make sure no one adds a major 3rd |
|
|
|
b0b
From:
Cloverdale, CA, USA
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 5:56 pm
|
|
Cm11 - that would be fine as a clue for improvising over it I suppose. It would certainly keep that dissonant E note out of the mix.
By the way, today I pointed out my dilemma to the band's official scribe - the singer/keyboardist - and she updated the chart as Bb/C which is what she's been playing. That works for me. 
_________________
-πππ- (admin) - Robert P. Lee - Recordings - Breathe - D6th - Video |
|
|
|
Ian Rae
From:
Redditch, England
|
Posted 29 Jun 2022 10:03 pm
|
|
Guitarists need to label chords without analysing them.
Depending on the genre, C11 can also mean Gm7/C, i.e. everything but the 3rd. The 11th is indeed heard as a suspended 4th, whether or not it resolves.
_________________
Make sleeping dogs tell the truth!
Homebuilt keyless U12 7x5, Excel keyless U12 8x8, Williams keyless U12 7x8, Telonics rack and 15" cabs |
|
|
|
Mike Neer
From:
NJ
|
Posted 30 Jun 2022 6:00 am
|
|
Using slash chords in a lot of cases helps arrangers get closer to the sound they want to hear from their chordal instruments. If you see Bb/C in a chart instead of C11, it keys you in to the fact that they want to hear the Bb triad. If it was Bbmin/C, would you prefer to see C11b9? Nope.
_________________
Links to streaming music, websites, YouTube: Links |
|
|
|
Roger Rettig
From:
Naples, FL
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 4:10 am
|
|
If I'm going to suddenly stumble on it, give me the slash-chord (Bb/C); I can instantly respond to that, either on guitar or steel.
It's even easier on my 'new' split on E9. With A and B pedals down, my RKR (since I tweaked it yesterday) now cancels out the 10th string raise.
1st fret, strings 10,6,5,4, A and B and my RKR (it normally lowers 9 and 10 to C# and A) = Bb/C.
It's equal to the old Isaacs pedal that just raised 5 and 6 (C#,A) but didn't raise the low B. |
|
|
|
Jim Fogle
From:
North Carolina, Winston-Salem, USA
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 8:43 am
|
|
I looked it up using my PG Music Guitar Chord dictionary and it said that is a C9SUS11. It gave several alternate names but I cleared them off to avoid confusing myself.
_________________
Remembering Harold Fogle (1945-1999) Pedal Steel Player
Dell laptop Win 10, i3, 8GB, 480GB
2024 BiaB UltraPlus PAK
Cakewalk by Bandlab software & Zoom MRS-8 hardware DAWs
Zoom MRS-8 8 Track Hardware DAW |
|
|
|
scott murray
From:
Asheville, NC
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 8:58 am
|
|
C9sus#11?
odd way to label it and incorrect since there is no #11 (raised fourth/flatted fifth). Bb/C isn't quite right either since the G note is included. Gm7/C or C9sus4 is most accurate 
_________________
1965 Emmons S-10, 3x5 β’ Emmons LLIII D-10, 10x12 β’ JCH D-10, 10x12 β’ Beard MA-8 β’ Oahu Tonemaster |
|
|
|
Roger Rettig
From:
Naples, FL
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 9:28 am
|
|
| I agree, Scott, but I'd sooner see it written 'Bb6/C'. |
|
|
|
Dave Mudgett
From:
Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 10:53 am
|
|
C9sus#11 is just wrong. There's no #11 in this chord rooted in C.
I agree with Mike that I'd prefer to see slash chords than some 'technically correct' 11th chord notation because the latter doesn't tell you two critical things: 1. the bottom note/inversion, and 2. what interval(s) are missing. This chord has all of the 1,3,5, and 6 intervals in the key of Bb, so Bb6/C is entirely accurate and pretty unambiguous except for the exact order of the notes.
As far as my general preference of exactly which root to choose, I would generally defer to how the chord is being used in context, so that I'm on the right track when I (frequently) eliminate notes when comping. |
|
|
|
b0b
From:
Cloverdale, CA, USA
|
Posted 1 Jul 2022 11:22 am
|
|
I think it's a Gm7/C in this context. Our band's scribe changed the C11 to Bb/C and I'm okay with her decision. Makes it easy to find anywhere on the neck. C11 is harder and, more importantly, it was the wrong chord.
Dave: PG Music has some strange ideas about chord names in BIAB as well. I don't trust them.
_________________
-πππ- (admin) - Robert P. Lee - Recordings - Breathe - D6th - Video |
|
|
|
